About This Episode
An HR analyst is quietly charging $400 an hour for AI prompt engineering on nights and weekends, and her manager finds out from LinkedIn. There's no moonlighting policy and no obvious violation. Leslie Barkett Laws, VP of People Labs at Thumbtack, and Rebecca Taylor cover separating facts from a manager's fears, how confidentiality and IP agreements can create disclosure duties anyway, why proving company AI use is hard, and when a conversation should become an investigation.
About The Guest
Leslie Barkett Laws is VP of People Labs at Thumbtack, the online marketplace that connects people with local service professionals. She leads the company's AI transformation work and a people products team that partners closely with engineering, data science and technical program managers. Before that she spent years leading HR business partner teams, and earlier people roles include Head of People at brightwheel, so she knows the day-to-day pressure of employee relations firsthand. She's based in Miami.
Episode Breakdown

An HR analyst charges $400 an hour for AI prompt engineering on nights and weekends, and her employer has no moonlighting policy. Her manager finds out from a LinkedIn post. Suddenly the questions are about loyalty, distraction, and whether she used company-licensed AI tools for personal gain. When host Rebecca Taylor worked through the scenario on HR Voices with Leslie Barkett Laws, VP of People Labs at Thumbtack, the first thing Leslie examined was not the analyst. It was the manager.

Leslie leads AI transformation work and a people products team at Thumbtack, after years leading HR business partner teams. She calls the AI shift “a massive technical problem and a massive change management problem.” The same scenario came up in an earlier episode with Miriam Chan of Miro; Leslie started instead from the obligations the analyst already had.

Why a Manager’s Surprise Is Not Evidence of Misconduct

Leslie’s warning was plain: do not “confuse surprise with misconduct.” Nothing in the facts says the analyst’s work slipped. There were no late arrivals, no drop in quality, and no poor review.

Her test for the manager is whether anything was going wrong before the post, or whether everything became suspect only because the post came as a shock. Good HR partners, in Leslie’s view, make the manager check that. Rebecca knew the pattern from her own HR career: managers arrive with a worry that has already hardened into an accusation. The work is separating what is happening from what might happen.

Leslie also saw an upside. An analyst doing people analytics work who earns $400 an hour prompting is, in her words, “a gift to an employer,” and the role could grow to use that skill. Rebecca added the money: three hours a week is $1,200 a week, income a company would have to reckon with before asking her to stop.

What an Employee Owes Without a Moonlighting Policy

A missing moonlighting policy is not a missing obligation. Leslie’s first step is to list what the company already has: a signed confidentiality agreement, an intellectual property agreement, and the code of conduct. Any of them can create a duty to disclose outside work. The employer’s core question is what it needs to protect, mainly trade secrets that could seep through AI tools to outside clients.

Proof is harder than it sounds. Rebecca expected company AI use to be easy to confirm; Leslie disagreed. Many tools now keep trace logs, but an employee with personal and company accounts blurs where one ends and the other begins. That blur is common. The 2024 Work Trend Index from Microsoft and LinkedIn put the share of AI users bringing their own AI tools to work at 78 percent.

The tools question also shapes ownership. In California, Labor Code section 2870 bars an employment agreement from claiming an invention built entirely on the employee’s own time without the employer’s equipment, supplies, facilities, or trade secret information, unless it relates to the employer’s business or results from work for the employer.

What Actually Works

Make a Plan Before the Manager Says a Word

Leslie’s first call for the manager is to an HR business partner, or to HR or legal where there is no HRBP. That partner plans the conversation and keeps the manager from saying something that causes trouble later. With no rule on the books, the response is a conversation that seeks to understand.

She would also open a second work stream. If one employee is doing this, Leslie assumes others are, because AI is “massively lowering the barrier” to becoming an entrepreneur. Companies have to decide whether they are ready for people with “multiple professional identities” at once. They do not own every ounce of someone’s ambition.

Design the First Conversation as Triage

Leslie does not want the manager questioning a direct report. The power dynamic works against honest answers. She prefers a neutral internal third party, coached by IT or security on the technical questions. That conversation covers the initial facts and a credibility assessment. If the employee is open and the work carries no conflict of interest with the business, Leslie would confirm the IP is safe and stop there.

Red flags change the answer. If credibility seems off, or the conduct could expose the company to real risk, a formal workplace investigation is reasonable. Rebecca disagreed on timing. She would open one early and document everything, since the file can explain why a new policy exists. Leslie’s concern is the label. Investigations carry a negative connotation, and “as soon as you attach that word to a situation,” it means something different to the employee.

Tie Approval to Written Terms

Rebecca would set conditions if the side work continues, with a dip in performance as the trigger to revisit. Leslie noted that approvals typically carry those provisions already: no impact on performance, no conflict with the business, both in writing.

The same paper protects the employee. If the side practice grows into a full-time business, Leslie wants written clarity that the employee owns it. Rebecca agreed: with it in writing, the employee can walk away with the work and say it is theirs.

Where Employee Relations Fits

Nothing in this case began as a complaint. It began as a manager’s reaction to a LinkedIn post, which is how a lot of employee relations casework starts. Leslie and Rebecca disagreed on when to call it an investigation, not on keeping a record. The first conversation, the credibility read, the decision to escalate, and the approval terms belong in one file. If more employees run side practices, HR needs to see the later cases next to the first.

Frequently Asked Questions About Employee Side Hustles and AI

Does an Employee Have to Disclose a Side Business Without a Moonlighting Policy?

Often, yes. A confidentiality agreement, an IP agreement, or the code of conduct can create a disclosure duty for outside work. Leslie’s advice to employees is “when in doubt, disclose,” ideally with written approval from the employer.

Can HR Prove an Employee Used Company AI Tools for Side Work?

Not always. Many AI tools keep trace logs, but personal and company accounts blur together. Leslie recommends a careful conversation that assumes good intent, since both sides tend to share more when neither feels threatened from the start.

When Should a Side Hustle Concern Become a Formal Investigation?

Only after the first conversation raises red flags. Leslie would open one if the employee’s credibility seems off or the conduct carries real risk. If the employee is open and no company tools were involved, a broad investigation is probably unnecessary.

Who Owns What an Employee Builds on a Side Hustle?

The agreements decide it. An IP agreement may give the company a claim. Leslie recommends written clarity that the employee owns the outside work, so both sides know where the line sits if the business grows.

Should the Manager Question the Employee Directly?

No. Leslie warns that a manager questioning a direct report creates a power dynamic that is unlikely to produce the best answers. A neutral internal third party, coached by IT or security, is the better choice, and the manager’s first call is to HR.

The Bottom Line for HR Leaders

Leslie Barkett Laws closed with one line for each side. For employees, “when in doubt, disclose,” because written approval ends the speculation and can lead to more opportunity. For employers: “Clarity protects everyone.” That means an outside activity policy the company can enforce and explain, revisited as AI blurs the line between a job and a second professional identity.

Her last point was about intent. Leslie believes most people “want to work with integrity,” and assuming that on both sides is how HR reaches the right answer while the rules keep shifting.

See how AllVoices helps ER teams record the early conversations in a side-hustle case, so the file is already there if it becomes an investigation.

Our next webinar
Frequently asked questions

Got more questions? Email us at support@allvoices.co and we'll respond ASAP.

No items found.
Frequently asked questions

Got more questions? Email us at support@allvoices.co and we'll respond ASAP.

No items found.

An Employee's AI Side Hustle and No Moonlighting Policy to Cite

About the guest

Leslie Barkett Laws is VP of People Labs at Thumbtack, the online marketplace that connects people with local service professionals. She leads the company's AI transformation work and a people products team that partners closely with engineering, data science and technical program managers. Before that she spent years leading HR business partner teams, and earlier people roles include Head of People at brightwheel, so she knows the day-to-day pressure of employee relations firsthand. She's based in Miami.

Episode Breakdown

An HR analyst charges $400 an hour for AI prompt engineering on nights and weekends, and her employer has no moonlighting policy. Her manager finds out from a LinkedIn post. Suddenly the questions are about loyalty, distraction, and whether she used company-licensed AI tools for personal gain. When host Rebecca Taylor worked through the scenario on HR Voices with Leslie Barkett Laws, VP of People Labs at Thumbtack, the first thing Leslie examined was not the analyst. It was the manager.

Leslie leads AI transformation work and a people products team at Thumbtack, after years leading HR business partner teams. She calls the AI shift “a massive technical problem and a massive change management problem.” The same scenario came up in an earlier episode with Miriam Chan of Miro; Leslie started instead from the obligations the analyst already had.

Why a Manager’s Surprise Is Not Evidence of Misconduct

Leslie’s warning was plain: do not “confuse surprise with misconduct.” Nothing in the facts says the analyst’s work slipped. There were no late arrivals, no drop in quality, and no poor review.

Her test for the manager is whether anything was going wrong before the post, or whether everything became suspect only because the post came as a shock. Good HR partners, in Leslie’s view, make the manager check that. Rebecca knew the pattern from her own HR career: managers arrive with a worry that has already hardened into an accusation. The work is separating what is happening from what might happen.

Leslie also saw an upside. An analyst doing people analytics work who earns $400 an hour prompting is, in her words, “a gift to an employer,” and the role could grow to use that skill. Rebecca added the money: three hours a week is $1,200 a week, income a company would have to reckon with before asking her to stop.

What an Employee Owes Without a Moonlighting Policy

A missing moonlighting policy is not a missing obligation. Leslie’s first step is to list what the company already has: a signed confidentiality agreement, an intellectual property agreement, and the code of conduct. Any of them can create a duty to disclose outside work. The employer’s core question is what it needs to protect, mainly trade secrets that could seep through AI tools to outside clients.

Proof is harder than it sounds. Rebecca expected company AI use to be easy to confirm; Leslie disagreed. Many tools now keep trace logs, but an employee with personal and company accounts blurs where one ends and the other begins. That blur is common. The 2024 Work Trend Index from Microsoft and LinkedIn put the share of AI users bringing their own AI tools to work at 78 percent.

The tools question also shapes ownership. In California, Labor Code section 2870 bars an employment agreement from claiming an invention built entirely on the employee’s own time without the employer’s equipment, supplies, facilities, or trade secret information, unless it relates to the employer’s business or results from work for the employer.

What Actually Works

Make a Plan Before the Manager Says a Word

Leslie’s first call for the manager is to an HR business partner, or to HR or legal where there is no HRBP. That partner plans the conversation and keeps the manager from saying something that causes trouble later. With no rule on the books, the response is a conversation that seeks to understand.

She would also open a second work stream. If one employee is doing this, Leslie assumes others are, because AI is “massively lowering the barrier” to becoming an entrepreneur. Companies have to decide whether they are ready for people with “multiple professional identities” at once. They do not own every ounce of someone’s ambition.

Design the First Conversation as Triage

Leslie does not want the manager questioning a direct report. The power dynamic works against honest answers. She prefers a neutral internal third party, coached by IT or security on the technical questions. That conversation covers the initial facts and a credibility assessment. If the employee is open and the work carries no conflict of interest with the business, Leslie would confirm the IP is safe and stop there.

Red flags change the answer. If credibility seems off, or the conduct could expose the company to real risk, a formal workplace investigation is reasonable. Rebecca disagreed on timing. She would open one early and document everything, since the file can explain why a new policy exists. Leslie’s concern is the label. Investigations carry a negative connotation, and “as soon as you attach that word to a situation,” it means something different to the employee.

Tie Approval to Written Terms

Rebecca would set conditions if the side work continues, with a dip in performance as the trigger to revisit. Leslie noted that approvals typically carry those provisions already: no impact on performance, no conflict with the business, both in writing.

The same paper protects the employee. If the side practice grows into a full-time business, Leslie wants written clarity that the employee owns it. Rebecca agreed: with it in writing, the employee can walk away with the work and say it is theirs.

Where Employee Relations Fits

Nothing in this case began as a complaint. It began as a manager’s reaction to a LinkedIn post, which is how a lot of employee relations casework starts. Leslie and Rebecca disagreed on when to call it an investigation, not on keeping a record. The first conversation, the credibility read, the decision to escalate, and the approval terms belong in one file. If more employees run side practices, HR needs to see the later cases next to the first.

Frequently Asked Questions About Employee Side Hustles and AI

Does an Employee Have to Disclose a Side Business Without a Moonlighting Policy?

Often, yes. A confidentiality agreement, an IP agreement, or the code of conduct can create a disclosure duty for outside work. Leslie’s advice to employees is “when in doubt, disclose,” ideally with written approval from the employer.

Can HR Prove an Employee Used Company AI Tools for Side Work?

Not always. Many AI tools keep trace logs, but personal and company accounts blur together. Leslie recommends a careful conversation that assumes good intent, since both sides tend to share more when neither feels threatened from the start.

When Should a Side Hustle Concern Become a Formal Investigation?

Only after the first conversation raises red flags. Leslie would open one if the employee’s credibility seems off or the conduct carries real risk. If the employee is open and no company tools were involved, a broad investigation is probably unnecessary.

Who Owns What an Employee Builds on a Side Hustle?

The agreements decide it. An IP agreement may give the company a claim. Leslie recommends written clarity that the employee owns the outside work, so both sides know where the line sits if the business grows.

Should the Manager Question the Employee Directly?

No. Leslie warns that a manager questioning a direct report creates a power dynamic that is unlikely to produce the best answers. A neutral internal third party, coached by IT or security, is the better choice, and the manager’s first call is to HR.

The Bottom Line for HR Leaders

Leslie Barkett Laws closed with one line for each side. For employees, “when in doubt, disclose,” because written approval ends the speculation and can lead to more opportunity. For employers: “Clarity protects everyone.” That means an outside activity policy the company can enforce and explain, revisited as AI blurs the line between a job and a second professional identity.

Her last point was about intent. Leslie believes most people “want to work with integrity,” and assuming that on both sides is how HR reaches the right answer while the rules keep shifting.

See how AllVoices helps ER teams record the early conversations in a side-hustle case, so the file is already there if it becomes an investigation.