Find It Before Opposing Counsel Does: Using Your ER Data to Spot Patterns Early
Every prior complaint, exit interview, hotline report, and Slack thread in your company is discoverable, whether or not anyone in HR has read it. If a pattern sits in that record, someone will find it. The only open question is whether it is your investigator during the workplace investigation or opposing counsel during discovery.
AI makes those dots easier to connect, and it does so for both sides. A team that finds the pattern first can act on it. A team that never looked will meet it for the first time in someone else’s exhibit.
On October 28, Rebecca Taylor of AllVoices took that premise to Alissa Horn, global employee relations leader at Mattel, and Justin Jackson, a senior HR business partner and employee relations leader previously at Nu-Vu Glass and Amy’s Kitchen. Horn has spent 26 years in HR and ER, the last 14 of them specializing in employee relations and investigations at three companies. Jackson has worked mostly in manufacturing HR, where the job depends on being visible and building the relationships that get people talking.
Rebecca opened with a poll on how each team found out about the last pattern it caught. In the results read out during the session, 46% of attendees said an investigator remembered a similar case, 33% said they had not caught one that they knew of, and 9% said a lawyer, a demand letter, or a lawsuit told them. None of the three is an attorney, and the session was framed as education, not legal advice.
Where should you look first when a new complaint lands?
In what the company already knows about the people involved, before the new complaint itself. Rebecca asked where each speaker goes looking first, and Jackson answered with a reframe.
Maybe don’t start with the complaints necessarily, but start with what the company knows. What do we already know about the situation? Does this occur on a regular basis with other people? Is it just a normal part of the company culture? - Justin Jackson, senior HR business partner and employee relations leader
Horn agreed, and named what makes that question answerable. The history has to live somewhere an investigator can search on day one, which is the job of HR case management.
It’s so important that every organization and investigator has some way of tracking their cases. So that there’s a system or a mechanism where all of your cases are documented, where all of the investigation documents are stored so that when a complaint comes in, you can search by the name of the complainant. - Alissa Horn, global employee relations leader at Mattel
Searching by the subject’s name matters as much. Together, the two searches show the historical concerns about each person and how each one was handled.
Jackson pushed the search wider than the case system. When an employee has transferred, talk to leaders on the team they came from, whether that team sits in the same location or another building. When someone left and was rehired, read what they wrote on the way out.
Transfers, people resign, and then they come back, look at their resignation letter, their exit interview from the first time they left. I’ve got really good information from those. - Justin Jackson
Horn added the limit. The history you pull should stay tied to the allegation in front of you. An investigator who wanders past it is creeping the scope, and a file that wanders can be read as a witch hunt.
Look widely for the history. Look narrowly at the allegation.
Is a string of unsubstantiated allegations still a pattern?
Yes, and the reasons behind each finding are part of it. Horn drew the distinction that framed much of the session: a pattern in allegations and a pattern in substantiations are two different sets of data.
A pattern in substantiations points to a clear path, whether that is training, an employment change, or remedial work. A pattern in unsubstantiated allegations can point somewhere else. If employees keep reporting something the investigations do not bear out, the organization still has a perception to address.
Horn then took it one layer down, with an example of a manager facing a fifth harassment allegation.
The allegations in and of itself are only part of the pattern. But as the investigator, it’s important to review those case files and understand why were those allegations unsubstantiated. - Alissa Horn
The questions Horn asks of the old files are concrete. Did the conduct not happen? Was it handled as a conduct issue rather than harassment, which company policy defines precisely? Four closed cases can mean four different things, and only the files tell you which.
Jackson raised a second way patterns hide: in the labels. A manager writes an employee up for communication, then for disrespect, then logs a management concern. Each entry looks minor on its own.
Is it the thing that the employee is doing, or is there a pattern hidden behind the labels of communication, respect, or management concern that needs to be dug into deeper and looked at? - Justin Jackson
Rebecca added that the category of an allegation is a pattern of its own. Some categories carry more legal weight than others, and a run of compliance or retaliation complaints deserves a different response than a run of communication complaints.
Is a low number of employee complaints a good sign?
No. Horn reads a low case count as a sign that employees do not know how to raise concerns or do not trust the process. Rebecca had asked whether capturing more allegations is worth the extra workload, at a time when AI makes allegations easier to write.
I want more cases. The absence of cases does not mean necessarily an absence of issues. Generally, when an organization has a low case number relative to their employee population, it means that employees don’t know how to raise their concerns. They don’t have trust in the process. - Alissa Horn
Rebecca connected volume to the theme of the session. Patterns are only as reliable as the inputs they are drawn from, and employees do not describe problems in HR’s language. Someone may file a retaliation complaint about conduct that does not meet the legal meaning of the word. Rebecca’s experience is that many such reports end up unsubstantiated or reclassified as something else, and the reclassification is useful data too.
People also raise things late. An employee may witness the same behavior several times before deciding to say anything, which is why some concerns surface months after the event. Rebecca argued that managers can be trained to recognize when a question in a Slack message or an email looks like a possible complaint, without making anyone paranoid.
Horn sets the bar for managers lower than that. Horn tells people managers and HR partners alike that they are not expected to be the experts on what needs investigating, and that deciding is the investigator’s job. Their job is to bring the question. The alternative is learning six months later that an issue needed investigating. A manager who asks too often costs a conversation. A manager who never asks can cost a case.
Does every employee complaint need a formal investigation?
No. Horn separates investigations with a capital I from investigations with a lowercase i, and handles them differently.
Investigations with a capital I are things like harassment, discrimination, retaliation, hostile work environment, things that could be violation of company policy. Investigations with a lowercase I are those things like unprofessional conduct, where it may be more interpersonal issues and communication. - Alissa Horn
Every organization draws its own lines, including whether a separate investigations function exists or HR partners handle everything. Horn’s condition is that once the lines are drawn, they are applied consistently. Rebecca added the reason. If your investigation is examined later, you will need to explain any departure from your own process.
Capital I or lowercase i
| Investigation with a capital I | Investigation with a lowercase i |
|---|---|
| Harassment, discrimination, retaliation, hostile work environment | Unprofessional conduct and interpersonal friction |
| Could be a violation of company policy if true | More often a communication problem than a policy violation |
| A manager who hears it is required by policy to escalate it | Often resolved with feedback and coaching |
| Explained against a consistent process if challenged | A one-off may only need a dated note while you watch for a pattern |
An attendee tested the line with a live example: a new partner had apparently said something rude to a colleague, possibly in tone more than words. Horn’s first question was what he actually said. Tone alone gives an investigator little to work with, and a single incident would not warrant even a lowercase i. It still warrants watching.
Rebecca’s habit for that situation is a short email note, sent so the incident has a timestamp. An attendee pointed out what that buys you: a starting date if the behavior becomes a pattern. Horn added one more option, which is making sure employees know they can raise a tone problem directly with the colleague, professionally, when they feel comfortable doing so.
What should HR do when a new allegation surfaces mid-investigation?
Open it as its own case, and give it its own time. Horn has seen it happen, often from something buried in an email thread that nobody had followed up on.
In Horn’s view, recognizing that a separate investigation is needed is the investigator’s responsibility, and so is deciding whether someone else should run it. Horn has handed cases off more than once after handling earlier investigations involving the same person, so that nobody could question the overlap.
Jackson argued that this only works when the process is written down: who is responsible for what, and what a manager must pass to ER or HR, and when. Jackson has worked in organizations without one and had to build it, because concerns otherwise get dropped and forgotten. A documented process is also what you show counsel. In Horn’s experience, a manager’s obligation to escalate a possible policy violation is written into policy, so failing to escalate is itself a violation.
An attendee asked what happens when an employee mentions something from three to six months earlier. Both speakers were clear that the obligation to investigate remains. Horn asks why it was not raised before, framed so the employee does not hear an accusation.
There’s no right or wrong answer to this question, but your answer is gonna be helpful to me. Is there a reason that you didn’t raise it previously? - Alissa Horn
The answer tells you where your reporting process is failing, even when it says nothing about the allegation. Jackson and Horn both tell the employee the new concern will be looked at separately and will not change the outcome of the current case. Horn schedules a dedicated conversation for it.
Jackson also asks for these concerns on purpose, at the end of an interview so the question does not hang over the whole conversation.
You’re busy. I’m busy. But is there anything in your work that you’ve wanted to talk about, but you haven’t? - Justin Jackson
Employees who saw what happened to the last person who spoke up rarely volunteer. Asking gives them the opening.
What should HR say when a leader protects a top performer?
Ask whether the same decision would stand for the lowest performer. Rebecca described a company where one person drew similar allegations of favoritism and harassment, again and again, and kept leading teams because each case was unsubstantiated. When Rebecca raised it, the explanation was that the person was a top performer.
Horn separated two moments. Whether an investigation happens is not a business manager’s call. What happens after a substantiated finding is where the pushback arrives.
I recommended based upon my findings a certain disciplinary action, and I’ve had a manager go, that person’s my top performer. I can’t do that. And my question to them is, if this person was your lowest performer, would you do it? - Alissa Horn
If the answer is yes, the manager has to explain how performance factors into a substantiated violation of policy. Rebecca turned the usual argument around.
You say we can’t afford to lose them, but given the allegations, can we afford to keep them? - Rebecca Taylor, head of community and content at AllVoices
The cost of keeping them is not limited to a possible lawsuit. Rebecca pointed to the damage a continuing pattern does to productivity and culture inside the company, which is why the earlier, unsubstantiated cases still need to be stored and findable.
Horn was careful about where HR’s authority ends. The final call may be a business decision. HR’s job is to make sure the leader making it has heard the question it will face later: why the lowest performer and the highest performer were treated differently for the same violation. Horn’s test for the answer was blunt. Picture it as a newspaper headline, or as the crawl at the bottom of a cable news screen.
What belongs in the investigation case file?
Whatever the investigator used to reach the findings. Rebecca set up the question with AllVoices’ position that AI can surface material from many places, but a person decides what enters the file.
A human should be the one that decides what actually gets added to the case file versus what’s dismissed. - Rebecca Taylor
Horn’s rule is simple. If it was used in the analysis that determined the findings, it goes in the case file. Everything else is kept. Horn invites subjects, complainants, and witnesses to send anything they think is relevant, and does not gatekeep at the door.
Material that played no part in the findings is saved, not deleted, and stays out of the formal file. Jackson described the same practice: the material is not removed, it is not applied to the matter at hand. Horn added why an open door protects the investigator. If a party chooses to withhold something, the determination can only rest on what was provided.
That discipline is what the session title asks for. Horn has had investigation records turned over in discovery, has been deposed, and has testified in arbitration. Horn’s standing advice is to conduct and document every investigation as if it will be scrutinized and you will have to answer for it, because you rarely know in advance which one will be.
It’s not about the quality of your investigation. That’s never what the allegation is about, but the quality of your investigation sets the organization up to defend. - Alissa Horn
The investigation report is where that quality is visible to whoever reads it next.
An attendee asked whether investigation documents belong in a terminated employee’s personnel file. In Horn’s practice they never have. Witnesses speak under confidentiality, and placing the file in one person’s record would break it. A union request under a contract that does not name record types gets the same answer you apply to everyone else, with employment counsel involved.
What an employee may see is set by state law, not by where you file the record. In California, current and former employees can inspect records relating to their performance “or to any grievance concerning the employee,” within 30 calendar days of a written request, according to the state’s Labor Commissioner. Ask counsel how your state treats investigation records before answering a request.
This is a summary of a panel discussion, not legal advice. Confirm your process with counsel.
Keep one record that outlasts the investigator
Put every case in one system the whole team can search. Horn noted that a team of one or two investigators may carry every case in memory, but a team of ten cannot. When two investigators handle the same person two years apart, only a shared record connects the cases.
Rebecca has seen investigations tracked in Google Docs, spreadsheets, and inboxes, and not only at small companies. People leave, and a file kept by one person leaves with them. Jackson described the alternative to a central record.
Because when you’re found with nothing, you are then having to go through Slack messages and emails and separate employee, maybe corrective actions. And there’s not one space for that to be. - Justin Jackson
Horn’s one condition on any tracker was that it be central and shared, not a set of individual records kept by each investigator. Rebecca described AllVoices’ workplace investigations software as built for that record: case notes, investigation workflows, and a case file you can hand to an attorney. The technology recalls what happened two years ago, and the investigator decides whether it matters now.
Find the pattern before discovery does
AllVoices keeps every complaint, its evidence, and each investigation step in one searchable record, so the history is there when the next case opens.
Request a demoHorn closed on how young this work is. Employee relations and investigations as a standalone function is less than about twenty years old, and conduct that is investigated today once went unreported. The Me Too movement changed how organizations trained for and investigated harassment. The record you keep now is the one the next investigator, or the next opposing counsel, will read.
Frequently asked questions
Yes. Horn has had investigation records turned over during discovery, has been deposed, and has testified in arbitration. The advice was to conduct and document every investigation as if it will be scrutinized, because you rarely know in advance which case will end up in front of a lawyer.
Not in Horn’s practice. Witnesses speak to investigators under confidentiality, and putting the investigation file into one employee’s personnel record would break it. What an employee may inspect varies by state, and a request for the personnel file does not entitle anyone to everything the employer holds. Check with counsel.
Yes. Both Horn and Jackson said the obligation to investigate remains when an employee raises something from three to six months earlier. Ask whether it was raised before and why not, framed as a question with no wrong answer, and handle it as a separate case from the current one.
Write it down with a date. Rebecca logs it in a short email so the incident carries a timestamp, and tells the team. A single rude comment rarely warrants an investigation, but if similar reports follow, the note gives you a starting date for the pattern.
It depends on the contract. Horn’s view is that when a collective bargaining agreement does not name the records a union may request, you apply the same standard you use across the organization. Investigation records are generally not part of standard personnel files, and employment counsel should review the request.
The investigator or ER function, not the business manager. Horn said a leader cannot rule out an investigation into a top performer because that decision is not theirs to make. Managers are expected to escalate possible policy violations and leave the judgment on what is investigatory to ER.



