Quid Pro Uh-Oh: What Office Romances Owe HR (and When)

Two employees start dating, and your team does what the handbook says. They disclose it, they sign a form, and the form goes into a folder. The box is checked.

The exposure rarely arrives that day. It arrives months later, when the relationship has ended and one of them still reports to the other, sits beside the other, or has a say in the other’s pay. An employee fraternization policy that stops at disclosure covers the easy half of the problem.

On September 2, Rebecca Taylor of AllVoices took up the harder half with Jessica Winder, chief people officer at Winder Law Firm. Winder has spent 15 years in HR, at a global employer with 10,000 people, in retail, and at companies small enough that there was nowhere to move someone. She also writes The Hidden Gem Newsletter on corporate careers.

Rebecca opened with a poll on where attendees stand on office romance. In the final count, 58% answered hard pass, 17% said fine until HR gets involved, 13% said cute if it is real, and 12% asked to be polled again afterward. Winder was in the 13%.

Is a consensual office romance any of HR’s business?

Less of it than most policies assume. Winder’s position is that once two colleagues have told HR and been separated on paper, what happens between them belongs to them.

Winder described walking through a parking lot and finding a disclosed couple kissing in a car. The two of them came to apologize afterward. The answer they got was that a car in a parking lot had nothing to do with HR, and the same rule covered the lunches they took together and anything else that harmed nobody.

As long as it’s not a problem for y’all and for everybody else, it’s not a problem for me. - Jessica Winder, chief people officer at Winder Law Firm

What stays HR’s business is narrower and easier to defend: who reports to whom, who can see whose pay, and what happens to both of those when the relationship is over. Rebecca framed the whole session around that last part.

The exposure of what happens in an interoffice relationship isn’t just about what happens when you’re in the relationship itself. It’s more about what happens when the relationship ends. - Rebecca Taylor, head of community and content at AllVoices

The limit matters for trust as much as for privacy. Rebecca recalled joining a company where managers dating their direct reports had been culturally accepted before she arrived, and being the person who had to end it. Asking who is dating whom can look like fishing for information, Rebecca noted, in a place where HR is new or not yet trusted.

If employees believe disclosure exists to protect them, they disclose. If they believe it exists to catch them, you learn about the relationship from someone else.

What should a workplace relationship policy ask couples to disclose?

Two things: that the relationship has started, and that it has ended. Winder and the HR team applied that policy at the 10,000-person employer, where relationships between colleagues were common enough that the offense was failing to mention one.

Dating a colleague was not a problem there. Staying quiet about it was. Once a couple came forward, HR did four things.

  • Separated the reporting lines. Neither partner could report to the other, and that stayed true after a couple married.
  • Closed off access. Neither could see the other’s compensation or benefits, and a partner who worked in HR was moved off that business unit.
  • Put in writing that nothing was promised. With the lines separated, neither partner had the authority to deliver a promised bonus anyway.
  • Required a second disclosure. A couple that broke up had to come back and say so, and the file was updated.

Winder summed up what the document is for.

The paperwork beforehand to me is just saying, hey, you two are separate. You’re adults. You’re declaring that there’s no power dynamic. You’re not being promised anything. - Jessica Winder

The second disclosure is the one most policies skip, and it is the one that tells you the working relationship has changed. Winder explained why it has to be a requirement. Left to themselves, former couples go silent.

Most of the time, they actually don’t want anybody involved. They want to just quietly be like, this didn’t work out. We’ve moved on and act like it never happened. - Jessica Winder

An attendee asked whether requiring disclosure invades privacy. Winder has never seen it become an issue, and has had couples ask to sign confidentiality agreements so that only HR knew. In one case involving a member of the executive team, four people knew: the couple, Winder, and the company’s attorney. The board was told because of the executive’s position, the other partner’s manager was not, and the executive signed a clause agreeing not to discuss executive-team matters at home.

Rebecca added that the penalty for staying quiet does not have to be termination. A couple that failed to disclose has broken a policy, and the response can be proportionate to what the silence put at risk.

What happens when one partner reports to the other?

The reporting line has to change, and where it cannot, one of the two has to leave. This was the one situation in which Winder, who sided with romance in the poll, would not bend.

A manager who dates a direct report still writes that person’s review and still influences that person’s pay. That is a conflict of interest at work no signed form can fix. At a company of 10,000, the fix is a transfer. At a small one, there may be nowhere to send anyone.

Winder described that second case. An employee and the manager above him began dating, and the company had no other team for either of them. HR told the couple that one of them would have to go, gave them 30 days, and offered to help plan the exit. The couple chose who. The manager, further along in her career, found another job and left with a strong reference.

The reason was structural, not moral.

She would have still been over his performance reviews, over his compensation, over all these things. There was no way to undo that in that situation, and that is when it will not work. - Jessica Winder

Rebecca pointed out what that story sounds like from the other side of the desk, and why couples in the same position stay quiet.

I think that’s why people are afraid to disclose because they see that as, HR is firing me because I told them that I’m dating someone. - Rebecca Taylor

The details of that exit are the reply to that fear. Nobody was fired, nobody was handed a decision, and the person who left did so with HR’s help. Employees watch how the first disclosed couple is treated, and that decides whether the second one comes forward.

When does a consensual relationship become quid pro quo?

When one of the two people does not feel free to say no. The clearest example of the session came from an attendee.

The attendee described a former peer, a head of HR, who was propositioned by the CEO. The peer did not believe it was possible to decline and stay employed. The affair lasted about a year, until the head of HR suffered professional consequences. The attendee doubted that it was consensual, and Winder did not hesitate.

That does not sound consensual. That sounds like pressure. Somebody feels like they cannot not do it. That’s not consensual. - Jessica Winder

Rebecca named the category. It is a quid pro quo harassment claim in the making, and one of the larger lawsuit risks an employer carries. The case also shows why this version is hard to catch. The person who would normally document the problem was the head of HR, and the other party was the only person above that role.

Winder drew a line under it. Everything said about disclosure and love contracts assumes a safe relationship, and this was not one. A form signed by two people only means something when both of them could have refused to sign.

Heads up

Consent is not a label the couple or the company gets to apply. The federal regulation on sexual harassment covers unwelcome sexual conduct when submission is “made either explicitly or implicitly a term or condition of an individual’s employment,” or when submission or rejection is used as the basis for employment decisions. A relationship that looked voluntary can still fit that description when one person believed refusing would cost the job.

This is a summary of a panel discussion, not legal advice. Confirm your process with counsel.

What should a love contract include?

A plan for the working relationship if the personal one ends, written for that couple. An attendee asked both speakers what they thought of love contracts, and Rebecca, who has written them, compared the document to a prenup.

Let’s work out the plan. Let’s work out the exit strategy for not the relationship itself, but for what the work situation is going to look like if this does go south. - Rebecca Taylor

In practice that meant sitting down with both people and walking through scenarios before any of them happened. One partner gets promoted and the other does not. The couple moves in together, breaks up, and is still sharing a home when both come to work. Each answer went into the document.

Rebecca’s objection is to the standard form that treats every couple alike. Her version is specific to the two people involved, and its value shows on the day tension reaches the office. You can pull it up and act on what was agreed, whether that is a move to another team or a reminder that both said it would not be a big deal.

A one-time form vs. a working agreement

One-time formWorking agreement
When it is usedSigned at disclosure, then filedPulled up again when tension reaches work
What it coversThat the relationship is consensualPromotions, moving in, and the breakup
How it is writtenThe same wording for every coupleWorked out with each couple
What it does at the endNothingSets out the transfer or the ground rules already agreed

Winder had not seen one written this way. Her own paperwork covered disclosure and reporting lines, and she called the approach new to her. She had already made the argument for it earlier in the session.

How it starts and how it ends is two different things. Who you married, who you divorced, two different people. - Jessica Winder

What should HR do when an office romance is only a rumor?

Ask the two people, separately and directly. Winder called that step one, and had done it recently.

I asked them, and they said no. They lied. And then they came back and said, actually, yes, but we were afraid. And we worked it out. But the offense was actually them lying. It was not that they were dating. - Jessica Winder

An attendee in the chat reported the same experience: the denial was the issue, not the relationship. That is worth telling employees plainly. In Winder’s case, an honest answer the first time would have ended the matter.

Winder also asks a follow-up when the answer is no, which is why anyone would think so. The answer is useful either way. Rebecca noted that chemistry between two colleagues is not always romance, and the rumor then becomes feedback the two of them need to hear.

Rebecca raised the other possibility, which is that the question is being used as a weapon. Between them, the speakers named what might sit behind it: a sense of favoritism, someone feeling isolated on a team, or a poor performer who wants attention elsewhere. A rumor is sometimes a complaint about something else, and it deserves a record either way.

How do you tell harassment from a bad breakup?

By the definition, and by whether anyone’s safety is in question. Rebecca saved this for the final question of the session, and Winder answered it with two descriptions.

A bad breakup is two people who no longer want to be together and may not want to be in the same room. Something happened, possibly an infidelity, and it ended badly. Harassment is a different category.

Harassment is a legal violation. Not only is it this is happening at the job, but if someone is truly being harassed, they can file a police report. They can go to the police station. - Jessica Winder

Winder tells both parties exactly that whenever she investigates a harassment complaint, and named safety as the biggest difference between the two situations. A former partner who will not make eye contact in the hallway is uncomfortable to work beside. A former partner who makes a colleague feel unsafe is something else.

Rebecca came at it from the complaint side. Harassment is a word employees use loosely, and a report that uses it may describe someone who feels unseen or uncomfortable. Those feelings can be real without meeting the legal standard for harassment, and they still need a response. The investigation is how you find out which one you have, and a past relationship between the two people is context the investigator needs from the start.

The file has to show how you reached the answer, because either party may challenge it.

You need to be able to package this stuff up and say, here’s our investigation. Here’s what we did. Here’s how we made our decisions and our conclusions. - Rebecca Taylor

When the breakup ends in a restraining order

An attendee asked what HR does at that point, and Winder had handled it. Two employees in the same building had been together for close to two years and had a child. After they separated, one of them sent HR a police report and a temporary restraining order, and said she would not return to the office while he was there.

The company’s lawyers advised that the order was temporary and that nobody had been convicted. HR offered both employees the option to work from home, and offered both of them therapy. She chose to work remotely. He later left for another job.

Winder was clear that the offer went to both, because each had a different account of what happened and HR was not the place to settle it.

Whatever accommodations you guys need, we basically were like, we don’t want to be involved in this. We also want you both to feel safe. - Jessica Winder

Rebecca suggested handling the arrangement the way HR handles any accommodation: log it, manage it, and close it when it is no longer needed. The record matters later. If either person’s performance drops, you will want to read that drop with the whole story in front of you.

See the whole story before you decide the case

AllVoices keeps each report, the evidence, and every step of the investigation in one case file, so the context is there when the next complaint arrives.

Request a demo

Plan for the ending while everyone still gets along

Write the policy for the breakup, not for the romance. Disclosure, separate reporting lines, and a conversation about what happens if it ends all cost little while two people are happy. None of them can be arranged in the week after they stop speaking.

Winder’s closing position was that employees are adults and should be treated that way, with one condition attached.

Know what you’re doing before you do it, eyes wide open. And be prepared. I don’t think it’s the worst thing in the world for one of you to get a different job. - Jessica Winder

Rebecca’s closing point was aimed at HR. The profession has seen the bad endings, which may explain the hard-pass majority in the poll, and that history turns into bias. When a complaint or a performance issue involves someone who is dating a colleague, the job is to look at it as if it were the first such case you had seen.

The harder gap is what never reaches you. Rebecca described HR roles with no anonymous reporting channel, where the fallout from a holiday party arrived only if someone chose to walk up and say it.

What always kept me up at night in HR was, what don’t I know that I should know? - Rebecca Taylor

AllVoices builds workplace investigations software for the cases that do arrive, so the complaint, the evidence, and each decision sit in one record you can hand over.

Most office romances end at a wedding or in a hallway where two people no longer look at each other. A few end in your office. What you put in writing while they were happy decides how that conversation goes.

Frequently asked questions

Is liking a coworker on a dating app sexual harassment?

No, not on its own. Both speakers treated a single like, or a single request for a date, as ordinary behavior between adults. Winder’s line is what happens after a no: an employee who keeps asking after being turned down has moved into conduct HR has to address.

Do employees have to tell HR when a workplace relationship ends?

Only if the policy says so, and the one Winder described did. At that employer, a couple that had disclosed a relationship also had to report the breakup, and the file was updated. The end of the relationship is when reporting lines and shared work matter most.

Can a company hire both spouses?

Yes, as two separate employees. Rebecca’s condition is that neither reports to the other and that the two are treated as separate employees from the offer through any exit. Winder adds a conversation first, so the couple understands that both incomes and both benefit plans will depend on one employer.

Should an employee be fired for hiding a workplace relationship?

Not automatically. Rebecca argued that failing to disclose is a policy violation with a range of possible responses, and termination is only one of them. In Winder’s recent case, the couple denied the relationship, came back to admit it, and the matter was worked out.

Are close friendships at work a favoritism risk?

Often a bigger one than romances. Winder has seen best friends in leadership make decisions as a unit, with nothing to disclose and nobody watching for bias. Couples tend to know they are being watched and behave accordingly. Close friends often do not.

Is calling a colleague a work wife or work husband a problem?

It is a boundary issue more than a policy issue. Both speakers dislike the labels, and Winder has heard them since starting in HR 15 years ago. Rebecca’s view is that HR should not police the phrase, and that the person using it should be the one to set the boundary.

Stay up to date on Employee Relations news

Sign up to our newsletter

Thank you! We look forward to meeting you soon
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again or use the email below to get support.
Join our newsletter for updates. Read our Terms